Before You Comment ...

I currently have a little issue with my commenting software. I will try to fix it as soon as possible. In the meantime, just click on the heading of the post that you would like to comment on. You will then get onto the individual post page and from there, the comment feature should work. Sorry for the overhead.

Friday, October 19, 2007

EU Reform - Lisbon Treaty on Its Way to Ratification

It came faster than expected - yesterday night, the European heads of state agreed on a text amending previous EU treaties after making some last-minute concessions to Poland and Italy. The representatives of Great Britain, the Netherlands and France again emphasized that the new treaty was merely an amendment and not a Constitution. Such a negation is not aimed at reducing the impact of the whole reform efforts. Rather the leader of these three countries try to avoid referenda in their countries that had been futile for past reform efforts within the EU.

Basically, however, the Lisbon Treaty (as the Reform Treaty is now called) is the formerly proposed EU Constitution minus symbolism. In particular, the treaty will streamline decision-making within the EU while boosting democratic control. The Charter of Human Rights will become legally binding for most member states and the representation of the EU in external matters will be harmonized. A more detailed description of the treaty features can be found here [FAZ, in German] and here [previous post].

The heads of state are now scheduled to gather again on December 13/14 to sign the Lisbon Treaty. Yet, this will not be the ending. The realization of the treaty will depend on the ratification by the individual member states - a hurdle that the Lisbon Treaty's predecessor could not pass. As of now, a referendum is only required in Ireland. Great Britain, the Netherlands and France try to avoid referenda. In Poland, we have the inverse situation: a referendum, although unlikely, would probably pass smoothly as the Polish people are quite enthusiastic about the EU whereas on the political level Europe skepticism seems to prevail.

We can only hope that the extensive negotiation procedures will bear fruits and that the member states will now stick to the compromise reached for the sake of the EU's future success.

Friday, October 12, 2007

Justive vs. Peace: The Role of the International Criminal Court in Northern Uganda

Today, I read a really interesting comment paper in the Weekly Update of the International Crisis Group: Justice in Conflict? The International Criminal Court and Peace Processes in Africa (by Nick Grono and Adam O'Brien). Focusing on the conflict in Uganda, the paper discusses the relationship between peace and justice. I was impressed by the positive impact of prosecutions by the International Criminal Court (ICC) on peace negotiations.

Wednesday, October 3, 2007

EU Reform Treaty: Settlement Reached

Yesterday, Portugal, which holds the current EU Presidency [website, in English], announced that the 27 judicial experts of the IGC 2007 [website, in English] reached an agreement on a text for the Reform Treaty. This treaty would constitute a large step forward for the European Union. There are, however, still some hurdles to pass. Most importantly, the treaty has still to be ratified by the 27 member states. In some countries, ratification involves referenda and such referenda had been the stumbling block for the previously drafted EU Constitution. In addition, Poland seems to insist on a privilege to bar disagreeable decisions. This request has been blocked by the Portuguese presidency because it was not part of the originally proposed Reform Treaty [earlier post]. Whether the current Reform Treaty will get through is therefore still in the air. For further information click here [report, in German]. I will post the agreed upon version of the Reform Treaty as soon as it is available in English.